• A
  • A
  • A
  • ABC
  • ABC
  • ABC
  • А
  • А
  • А
  • А
  • А
Regular version of the site

Pre-Defense of Maxim Gurin's PhD Dissertation Held

On May 18 at 5:00 PM, the HSE International Laboratory for Social Integration Research held the pre-defense of the PhD dissertation of the Laboratory's graduate student, Maxim Gurin.

Pre-Defense of Maxim Gurin's PhD Dissertation Held

Maxim Gurin

At the center of Maxim Gurin's dissertation research are supported living training projects for adolescents and young adults with intellectual disabilities, examined as a distinctive space for socialization and the construction of an inclusive living environment. The author proceeds from the premise that supported living is a residential-care-alternative technology — an alternative to both institutional care and continued cohabitation with parents — and analyzes which mechanisms of primary and secondary socialization are realized within these projects. The object of the study is the life arrangements of people with intellectual disabilities within supported living training projects, while the subject is the practices of constructing an inclusive living environment and their socializing effect. The dissertation's theoretical framework draws on the social model of disability, the concept of inclusive living space, an understanding of socialization as an individual's entry into society's objective world, and an approach treating values and practices as key analytical tools.

An important part of the work examines how, through the values of independence, choice, and respect for others, an inclusive living environment is built into the everyday life of supported living training projects. The pre-defense presented the dissertation's key propositions, including the claim that supported living training serves as a space of transition from primary to secondary socialization, promotes clients' maturation, and produces multilevel effects both for the projects' participants and for their parents. For clients, these effects include mastering daily living skills, expanding communication, participating in inclusive volunteering, gaining employment, and moving toward more independent forms of living; for parents, they include a reduction in overprotectiveness, the emergence of "respite" space, and a shift in expectations regarding their children's future.

The dissertation's academic supervisor is Roman Nikolaevich Abramov, Doctor of Sociological Sciences, Professor at the Department of Social Institutions Analysis, and Leading Research Fellow at the HSE International Laboratory for Social Integration Research. The reviewers were Olga Borisovna Savinskaya, Candidate of Sociological Sciences, Academic Director of the Doctoral School of Sociology, Associate Professor at the Department of Methods for Collecting and Analyzing Sociological Data, and Leading Research Fellow at ILSIR; and Daria Igorevna Prisyazhnyuk, Candidate of Sociological Sciences, Deputy Dean for Academic Affairs at the Faculty of Social Sciences, Associate Professor at the Department of General Sociology, and Leading Research Fellow at ILSIR.

The discussion of the dissertation focused on refining the theoretical framework, the logical structure of the text, and the alignment of key concepts with the empirical material. Daria Igorevna Prisyazhnyuk stressed the need for a sharper focus on the research problem, stronger argumentation for treating supported living training as an inclusive living space, and further work on defining the boundaries and barriers of this space and its influence on external environments. Daria Igorevna suggested more carefully cross-referencing the cases with one another and reconsidering whether their structuring into chapters effectively supports the study's central research question.

Maxim Gurin

Olga Borisovna Savinskaya noted that the inclusiveness of supported living must be rigorously argued and conceptualized, and that key concepts — such as "residential-care-alternative technology" — require more precise definition. Olga Borisovna emphasized the importance of elaborating the legal context and expert debates surrounding supported living, as well as the need to clearly align the study's objectives with its theoretical concepts and the propositions submitted for defense, including through the use of tables.

Viktoria Konstantinovna Antonova pointed to a problematic overlap between the wording of the central research question and the study's aim, stressing the need to articulate the research aim more clearly. She also noted that the theoretical framework requires further development — in particular, a more explicit correlation between theoretical approaches and methods of interpreting empirical data, as well as a clearer definition of the concept of "practices."

In her comments, Elena Rostislavovna Iarskaia-Smirnova suggested clarifying the relationship between socialization and the study's subject matter, and drew attention to the specificity of socialization among atypical groups and the potential value of the quality-of-life concept. Elena Rostislavovna proposed considering supported living as a space of participation for various actors, and suggested drawing more broadly on debates about the boundaries of integration and critiques of the concept of independent living.

Konstantin Nikolaevich Obukhov highlighted a lack of methodological reflection, noting in particular the need to show how the methods used relate to one another and how the study accounts for participants' subjectivity and agency. Konstantin Nikolaevich emphasized that reflection on the researcher's positionality and analytical methods is an essential part of dissertation work.

Maria Andreevna Kozlova placed particular emphasis on the need for more careful consideration of privacy within the inclusive living space of people with intellectual disabilities.

In closing the discussion, participants noted that the text presented shows strong potential for further developing the topic of socialization and maturation among people with intellectual disabilities in supported living training projects, and for opening new perspectives on the analysis of inclusive living space in the Russian context.